NicBuhrmanProjects's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[why link isnt a surgeon]

Interesting

I like how the cartoon used some of the conventions of the game for humor, it was used well. It wasn't astounding, or particularly hilarious... just enjoyable. Not a full rating because most your ideas in this cartoon aren't particularly original, just used in a situation that makes them comical.

Congrats to you though. This cartoon is Nintendo-related, therefore it will no doubt surpass 100,00 views here shortly.

-Nic

balbod responds:

yea anything game related on the front page will get allot of veiws.

[FYAT]

Enjoyed it, but here's what I don't understand.

I really enjoyed the cartoon. It was well-animated, sound effects were implemented in all the right places, timing was right, it was just great. What I don't understand is why people take off points because it was "too short". Some people who reviewed this, in the same sentence said they "loved it" or "enjoyed it", but took off points merely for length.

That makes no sense to me.

For one, it doesn't cost any money to watch cartoons on here, so It's not like people didn't get full value. In that light, people should base their review on content, and if a short cartoon manages to be just as enjoyable as a long cartoon, then it should be scaled appropriately. Just because it's missing "length" doesn't mean that it deserves to lose points. Adding length to this could have made it worse. People should appreciate the value of comedy that uses time effectively, not ones that are long-for-the-sake-of-long.

Excellent job.

-Nic